Sunday, June 22, 2008
Sex in the Small Town
Monday, May 5, 2008
BNW and 1984 similarities
- The first thing I noticed that was similar was that in BNW there is Henry Ford and in 1984 there is Big Brother. They are both looking out for you, Ford is more of a god though.
- Another similarity is the family situation. In BNW families are non-existent for the most part, they are frowned upon. In 1984 there are families but parents in that time do not want their children, those evil snot nosed things grown up to be literally be the death of their parents.
- The hiding of historical facts and other such things is also a similarity. In BNW they hide great works of literature, and in 1984 they hide anything that doesn't put the government in a good light.
- The governmental control over the people. In BNW they condition the people from birth and in 1984 they are always watching the citizens and if they mess up it is kaput.
- In both books sex is controlled. In one way that is good in another is absolutely horrible.
Wednesday, April 23, 2008
BNW vs. Our World Today
Friday, April 18, 2008
John vs. Lenina *hypnopaedia*
The difference in their teachings keeps them apart. Lenina was trained to believe that John is a savage and that he is dirty. Every time she is around him the different phrases that a etched in her brain come up and remind her that he is not worthy to be with her. John on the other hand has been reading Shakespeare and believes in romance and tragedies are a pair, you cannot have one with out the other. Another part of John's problem is that he seems to suffer the Oedipus complex far more than the average man, obviously in Lenina's world where there are no mothers that is not a problem, but for John it has to be terrible. The fact that he gets angry every time his mother is with a guy and how he hates all men just furthers to prove his problem.
Friday, April 11, 2008
Brave New World
The good thing I found about A Brave New World was that there is no disease, it is all taken care of during the "pregnancy". No STDs no crippling diseases, that is one thing I could get used to.
The no family part of a Brave New World is the part that bothers me the most. Yeah family causes tons of stress but they are an important part of who you become. Nature vs. Nurture comes into play here, if you do not have a real person to nurture you than what kind of person are you really going to become. Where is your personality going to come from, a box whispering under your pillow. I would have an annoying family any day.
Wednesday, April 2, 2008
Utopia Book 3
- The Senate decides the law
- No one is distinguished
- They are very open to different religions
- When an authority advises a person to choose death and the person agrees, they receive and honorable death. However, if they should choose death without the authority's approval then their body is thrown in a ditch without an honorable funeral.
- Polygamy and divorces are not allowed except in the case of adultery and perverseness. Then the victim can remarry but the adulterer cannot.
- The sick are kept isolated and comfortable
- Girls have to be 18 and men have to be 22 before they are allowed to marry.
- A bride and groom have to see each other naked before they get married.
The senate deciding the law is the way it should be, you do not want the entire village or city deciding, then everything would be greatly distorted. The fact that they do not have any one person appearing better than anyone else is excellent; no one wants to feel like they are not good enough. The fact that all religions are accepted is amazing, different beliefs often cause controversy. The whole ordeal with honorable and non-honorable deaths is a little strange, it seems to me that if a person commits suicide without authority figures okay then it is bad, but how does that work. In the Catholic Church suicide is a selfish sin, no matter what, so why is it okay in Utopia if a priest tells you you can commit suicide. I agree with the fact that polygamy and adultery are frowned upon, and remarriage after being cheated on is okay. I really think they have that one down. Keeping the sick away from the healthy is smart, and then the illness does not spread to the rest of the village. For women to wait until they are 18 to get married is the smartest thing I have ever heard. Girls are not prepared to make the decision of long-term commitment any earlier than that. Men being 22 is even smarter; man's maturity level compared to woman's is far lower. However, the seeing of your soon to be spouse naked before the wedding is a little hard for me to grasp. I understand the no surprised there. Although some religions forbid that and if the society if fully accepting of the different religions should they not also be accepting of the rules that are put down by those religions. It is just a little too hypocritical for me.
Monday, March 31, 2008
Utopia Book 2
- 10-16 people for the family size
- Honor and respect for elders
- Everyone has a love for learning
- 30-40 cities on the island and they all have the same laws
- Any man can freely walk into any house whatsoever
- Uniforms for everyone, the only distinction is between male and female and married and unmarried.
Regulating family size is ridiculous, plus who wants a house with up to 16 people living in it. Too many people can make a person go mad. Of course respecting one's elders is important and learning is a loveable thing. Having the same laws in every city is important because then there is no confusion on rule breaking. Personally, I would hate to have people just entering my house at random, just too weird. Uniforms I can understand, they make life less of a hassle. However there should be some room for individualism.
Friday, March 28, 2008
Utopia Book 1 Reading Notes
- A country should not have a reserve of soldiers during a time of peace
- Stealing is over punished
- The death penalty is unjust
- Killing people and controlling their death is divine action
- People with great wisdom should help and serve the king and the people
- Thieves should be made slaves for the person that catches them
Personally the perfect society in my mind seems stuffy and full of death. I mean for every crime it seems the death penalty is accepted. I can see that they believe that people will not want to commit a crime if death is the consequence. However, it is just a little too much for one to handle. I do however agree that those with great wisdom should help the king and the people. Many great minds working together is better than one dim mind trying to get everything done. A country should always have soldiers in reserve; you never know when you're going to be attacked. And slavery should never be the answer. It is far too barbaric for this supposed perfect society.
Tuesday, March 25, 2008
IDK
Later